Some children with Selective Mutism don’t just find talking hard. They find almost any request hard. Getting dressed, coming to the table, answering “How was your day?”. If your child goes into shutdown or meltdown at everyday demands, you may have come across the term PDA.
We see many children at the clinic with both Selective Mutism and a PDA profile. The good news is that they can learn to talk comfortably. The approach just needs some careful changes.
What is PDA?
PDA stands for Pathological Demand Avoidance. Many families and adults now prefer “persistent drive for autonomy”, or simply “demand avoidance”. It describes children who feel intense anxiety when something is expected of them, and who go to great lengths to avoid that feeling.
PDA isn’t a formal diagnosis in Australia. It’s usually described as a profile within Autism, and the research is still developing. What matters most to us is the pattern we see in your child, not the label.
How Selective Mutism and PDA overlap
Selective Mutism is an anxiety disorder. Children fear what will happen when people hear their voice, so they freeze or avoid talking. For a child with a PDA profile, being expected to talk is one more demand on a long list. Both conditions are driven by anxiety, and both can look like stubbornness from the outside. Neither is a choice.
The difference is in how wide the avoidance is. A child with Selective Mutism alone is often relaxed and cooperative until they’re expected to speak. A child with PDA may resist a game, a reward or even praise because it feels like someone else is in charge.
Why standard strategies can backfire
Our treatment for Selective Mutism is based on gradual, step-by-step exposure, supported by rewards. This works well for most children. For a child with PDA, though, a reward chart can feel like a contract they’re being pushed into. A direct question can feel like a trap. Even “Great talking!” can make them stop, because now there’s an expectation to do it again.
When this happens, it’s easy for adults to push harder. That usually makes things worse.
How we adapt treatment for children with Selective Mutism and PDA
We still use the same evidence-based strategies, including Sliding In. What changes is how we use them.
We give the child control. In one version of Sliding In, the child “moves the teacher”, deciding how close the teacher comes. We offer choices wherever we can: which game, who goes first, where to sit.
We use fewer direct demands. Instead of “What’s your favourite animal?”, we might say “I wonder which animal would win in a race”. We comment and think out loud, and leave space for the child to join in.
The child sets the pace. Our 10-point thermometer lets children rate how hard each step feels. They choose the next step, usually somewhere between 3 and 5.
We’re flexible with rewards and praise. Some children love a reward chart. Others do better with surprise rewards, rewards they design themselves, or no rewards at all. We keep praise low-key and specific.
We lower demands elsewhere. In parent sessions, we look at the day as a whole. When fewer demands are placed on a child at home and at school, they have more capacity for brave talking.
We follow their interests. Humour, silliness and their favourite topics keep anxiety down and make talking feel like their idea.
Working with schools
School is often the hardest place for children with both Selective Mutism and PDA. In our school video meetings, we help teachers spot hidden demands and swap direct questions for choices and non-verbal options. We also help them avoid public praise and build a calm, trusting relationship before asking for anything.
What to expect
Progress can be slower when a child has PDA or Autism alongside Selective Mutism, and that’s okay. Small, steady steps that the child owns tend to last.
We never punish or withhold privileges for not speaking. Our aim is for your child to feel safe enough to use their voice, on their own terms.
Getting help
The Selective Mutism Clinic offers treatment face-to-face in St Leonards, Sydney, and online anywhere in Australia. Read more about our neuro-affirming approach, see our FAQs, or get in touch to talk about whether our program suits your child.
More articles: What Is Selective Mutism? A Guide for Parents | Selective Mutism at School: Practical Tips for Parents & Teachers | Supporting Your Child When a School Psychologist Suggests “Give It Some Time” | Why Does My Child Talk at Home but Not at School? | CBT for Selective Mutism | Is Selective Mutism an Anxiety Disorder? | Speech Therapy, Play Therapy or Medication for Selective Mutism? | Selective Mutism or Shyness? How to Tell the Difference

Written by Dr Elizabeth Woodcock, Clinical Psychologist and Director of the Selective Mutism Clinic in St Leonards, Sydney. Elizabeth has over 20 years’ experience as a clinical psychologist and has seen or supervised more than 1,800 children, teenagers and adults with Selective Mutism. She runs the clinic’s webinars for parents, teachers and health professionals. Read more about Elizabeth


